It was so hard to choose the winners because the entries were amazing! Nonetheless, here it is!

honorable mentions: 

victoriarobinson64

i love the simplicity of this cover- and I actually like your version better than the original, so congratulations! PM winterinheaven for five honest comments!

third place: 

colorsandink i love the dark theme of this cover! please PM -verdant- for a custom graphic

second place: 

kerozeo I love this so much! The gif was certainly a bonus but the typography was very envy worthy. Great job! 

first place: 

splendiferously this gave me the absolute chills- I LOVE THIS! The creepy vibe is present here, and I think your execution of the prompt was wonderful!