#40 - Alternate Universe - Evil Onity AU

-...-

In this Alternate Universe, Mike and Tyler never went and visited the abandoned mansion. They never met Onity, and Onity never met them. Onity would spend so much more time alone in the mansion in a world he doesn't understand. He'd eventually go stir crazy.

Onity would eventually start trapping people within his mansion. Anyone who'd stumble around the forest, no matter their age. He'd force them to play games for their freedom. If they beat him, they get to live, and if they lost, he'd kill them.
Many of the people who he'd trap would try to escape or fight him upon any mention of a game and rules. Some would yell and scream and others would cry and some thought it was a joke. Only a select few have ever attempted to play.

Nobody trapped within the mansion has ever lived so far.
-...-

Some of the people this Onity has probably killed:

Doll - Played the game, didn't make it 15 minutes. There was never a chance for her anyway.

Andrea - Attempted to kill Onity upon being trapped by him. Felt being offered a game to live was an insult. Died before a game could even be talked over.

Sethan - Tried to work something out while discussing the game. Couldn't win so took the challenge head on. Played the game for what felt like weeks before death of exhaustion.

Brentwood - Came looking for his boyfriend, Sethan. Was lied to and told he could find Seth if he played the game. Learned half way through it was a lie and died shortly after.

He's probably killed a kid, a few dumb teens, an old man. The woman he stole his disguise from too.

-...-

So imagine this evil!Onity was aware of the other alternate universes existing, like Alex is.
Imagine he travels through those AUs in attempts to challenge his alternate selves. He becomes aware of Mike and Tyler's existence, and how he seems to be the only version of Onity who had never met them (not counting the AU in which unity was never kidnapped).

Imagine he goes to the Original AU in order to challenge the original Mike and Tyler.
Imagine the original Onity steps in and proposes to his evil self a deal.
"You beat me, you can play your games with them. But you must beat me, fair and square, no matter the game."
Onity enters a life or death game with his evil self.

Who wins?
Will there ever be a winner?