Anthony had recently come to the conclusion that Steven was much, much too good for him. It was something about his ability to be so awkward and dorky and silly, and yet still manage to make Anthony melt every time he smiles.

How was that even possible? Anthony had no idea.

All Anthony knew is that he loved Steven, and Steven deserved somebody who's better at planning than Anthony is.

The only movie Steven wanted to see was sold out, much to their dismay. Seeing Steven so upset wasn't how Anthony planned on spending his afternoon, so he quickly dragged his little buddy off to find something to eat.

They found a little frozen yogurt shop, a nice lady explaining that they had just opened recently.

Steven was ecstatic, to say the least. He rushed towards the place like the big child he is, only to trip over the curb as he tried to cross the street, sending him falling backwards. Anthony wasn't even sure how the hell Steven managed that, the curb wasn't very high and Steven surely saw it coming.... Right?

And even then, how the actual fuck did he end up going backwards?

Either way, Anthony knew exactly what he was going to do. He moved quickly, running up behind Steven in an attempt to catch him. He wanted to make it just like the movies, where the girl falls back into the boy's arms by accident. It would be perfect, because he could easily tease the other about it and then he'd get to see Steven all flustered...

The only issue with Anthony's plan, he realized, is that he couldn't pull it off. Reaching out towards the smaller male, Anthony was fully prepared to catch him.

But Steven grabbed onto his arm, and it all went to shit from there. The two fell over onto the street, Steven landing on top of Anthony in what had to be the least sexy pose in existence. Anthony gave an undignified squawk as he fell, Steven trying his best to not laugh.

A few people going by laughed, and some guy wearing a really cool hockey mask helped them up while giggling like he was insane.

They thanked the stranger, and made their way into the shop.

.

"Who the hell gets strawberries and marshmallows on frozen yogurt?"

Steven glared up at Anthony, stuffing a spoonful into his mouth instead of answering the question.

Anthony made a face, using his spoon to poke at Steven's bowl. "Won't the marshmallows get all cold and hard? And why strawberries? Cherries are where it's at, buddy."

Steven narrows his eyes, giving Anthony a challenging look. Anthony does all he can to not laugh, because holy shit he looks so cute when he's mad.

"Well maybe I wanted to change it up, okay? At least I'm more creative than you, with your stupid sprinkles and nothing else."

"Hey, hey, they're chocolate sprinkles. Don't disrespect the chocolate sprinkles, you prick."

Steven's thinking. He's thinking, and he's making some kind of plan, but Anthony can't figure out what that plan is and it worries him. Before he can even think to ask about the plan, Anthony's suddenly got a mouth full of yogurt and- were those strawberries?

The taste is oddly pleasant, and apparently it showed because Steven gives a confident little grin as he watches Anthony.

He looks good like that. Confident Ze is a good Ze, I hope he's like this more often. It's actually kinda hot if you thin-

"Not so bad now that you're thinking about it, huh Chilly Willy?"

"What kind of nickname is Chilly Willy?" Anthony raises an eyebrow, staring straight at the other.

Steven shrugs and laughs softly. "I don't know, it just kinda popped into my head. I like it though, it suits you. You're Chilly Willy now. My Chilly Willy."

Anthony can't help but smile at that. He wasn't just any plain old Chilly. He was Steven's Chilly, and he wouldn't have it any other way.

"Hey, don't I get to try some of yours?" Steven pouts over at Anthony, gazing longingly at Anthony's bowl of frozen yogurt.

Anthony just smiles, taking some on his spoon and holding it up to Steven's mouth.

"We probably look like a really gay couple right now." Steven smiles, a bit of yogurt on his chin.

Anthony looks at Steven, and gives a chuckle. "Well, considering you're here, we're probably a cute gay couple." He instantly realizes what he said, and can feel his face heating up by the second.

It only grows worse as Steven jokingly wipes the bit of yogurt off his chin, and then licks it off his finger in what Anthony assumed was an attempt to be seductive.

Holy hell, did it work.

Thinking quickly, Anthony stood up with a cry of "Oh hey, would you look at the time? We should get going if you wanna catch that movie, buddy!"

And then, like all good dates do, Anthony proceeded to drag Steven out of the building, tossing their bowls out as he passed a trash can.

.

"Anthony, why are you so scared? You're the one who wanted to see this, this was your ide-"

"O-oh fuck!" Anthony jumps as the girl on screen gets dragged out of a closet by some freaky killer guy. The killer had to pry the doors apart, making this loud, sudden bang that may or may not have startled Anthony.

Steven shakes his head, tapping his finger on the popcorn bucket as he laughs quietly. "How are you so scared? I swear, you're more terrified than those guys in the movie."

Anthony doesn't respond, instead he squeezes his eyes shut and tilts his head down towards his lap.

He hears Steven giggle besides him, and feels a hand patting his shoulder gently. "It's okay. You wanna leave?"

"No, no, I can do this." Anthony had chosen this movie with every intention of getting nice and cozy with Steven in order to 'protect him' or whatever couples do while watching super scary movies.

The only thing wrong with this plan was that Anthony was a huge baby when it came to anything horror-related. Then again, Ze might pity Anthony enough to hold his hand or something.

He opens his eyes, deciding that since the screaming had stopped, everything must be okay.

Instead, he gets to watch the killer jump out at some poor guy working on a generator.

Anthony flinches, staring down at his lap as he listens to the screams of the innocent, along with Steven's surprised little gasp.

They ended up leaving the theatre early, at Anthony's request and Steven insisting that they can just " go back to your place for some Mario Kart or something."

Instead, Anthony laid on his bed, feeling a little more nervous than he really should. There was no real reason for it, the movie maybe spooked him more than expected, or maybe Anthony was just a bigger baby than originally thought.

Steven, on the other hand, was loving this. He rubbed Anthony's back gently, then flopped next to him on the bed.

"What movie are we watching?"

"The lego movie. It was all I could find."

There was a mild feeling of guilt rising up inside of Anthony. He wasn't a very good date, he had shitty planning skills, and he couldn't imagine how Steven was putting up with all of this.

"I'm sorry for being such a shitty date, by the way. Worst first date ever, probably."

Steven looks at Anthony for a moment, then turns back towards the screen. He's thinking, but Anthony's not sure what it is.

A smaller, slightly colder body is suddenly pressed up against him, arms wrapped around Anthony as best they can and a head nuzzling into his shoulder.

He can feel Steven smile against his arm, and feel the soft breaths of his giggles as Steven whispers a happy "I think it was a pretty nice first date. We should do it again."

And Anthony can't help but smile back.

.

A/n: its 1:20 am, i cant sleep and so i wrote like 70% of this in maybe 30 mins please send help