🥀 ROUND 5 RANKINGS
Here are the list of winners and their respective prizes. Congratulations to everyone, you all did well. As you know, we have eliminations but since there are inactive users, I will be the one to choose who to get eliminated when it comes between the active ones is when I will have the voting of eliminated contestants.
I also changed the way the scoring will be done. I reduced from 120 points to 30 points for my scoring total.
Also, stha2501 wasn't able to give her scoring and ranking so that's why certain areas are blank. I couldn't wait for her because I am on a strict schedule.
Everything is fair since the winner is selected and judged from all areas and perspectives, not just mine only.
Just know that the level of importance is:
1st : Average Ranking
2nd : Total Score
3rd : Audience Votes
⑄ ◈ ⑄
The collage below is how I base my ranking, I compile it like this and I rank based on how I see the covers.
If you want to comment your own rankings, you may too. Let's see if our rankings are the same! That way, I can see how you would rank as a judge.
Contestants can give it a whirl too.
(Sorry if the quality is a bit low, the tiny details have been blurred out)
Comment here who would you place first?
Second?
Third?
Fourth?
Last?
⑄ ◈ ⑄
Also, I am a part of a lot of cool groups and events that I think you woulf be interested to know.
Shoutout to Antionicha and Miss_Sarcastic27 for creating WattshipDay which will take place on March 20th. They also have contests if you are willing to participate.
I am also a part of _GraphicQueens_ which will be updated and will take full effect soon, CLNCommunity a great community, you should check out some of their stuff, PrismPrideClub, it's also a wonderful community that I think people would be interested to partake in, and MoonlightGraphics-, they host great contests too which you might want to check out.
Everyone may choose to claim their mini prizes if they want to but if you're saving for an even bigger prize, you may choose to wait.
Having that said, the next round will be uploaded soon.
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 🏆Overall Winner and 🏆Mr. Littleworth Winner
Contestant: GeekGoddess-
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (4)
Creativity (5)
Neatness (4)
Font (3)
Overall Impact (4)
Total (25)
Co-Judges Scoring: 7.5 + 0
Total Score: 25 + 7.5 + 0 = 32.5
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 3rd
K's Ranking: 2nd
Aeriina's Ranking: 1st
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: Congratulations Cat!! You are first place for this round. I don't know if it's because you didn't have competition but let me tell you some things I really love. YOU FOLLOWED THE PLOT! Like, I am so glad that among the contenders here, you were the one who went for something unexpected and followed the plot. I love how you edited the cover and the colors. They really look like a children book. The only reason I rank it 3rd was because I didn't like how you wrote our names. Your username was so small and so thin that it was hard to read. My username would have been good if you made it all caps. Tip: don't space letters if you aren't using all caps and for cursive fonts. Other than that, not really much else to say. Good job!
Audience Votes: 13
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 🥇First Runner Up and🏆Umbrella Town Winner
Contestant: Velsper
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (4)
Technique (5)
Creativity (3)
Neatness (5)
Font (3)
Overall Impact (5)
Total (25)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6.5 + 0
Total Score: 25 + 0 + 6.5 = 31.5
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 1st
K's Ranking: 2nd
Aeriina's Ranking: 5th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: Yes Kyle! You go girl! Anyways, you would have definitely ranked higher but I guess not all judges feel the same way. I like the simple effectiveness of the cover. It's clean, it's what I want, it followed the prompt and I love the colors. I just wished the "town" was aligned with "umbrella" so that the cover looks even and maybe the space above could feel a bit fuller. Beautiful work! One of my favorites this round, you definitely nailed this style.
Audience Votes: 12
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 🥈2nd Runner Up and🏆Gold in the Sky Winner
Contestant: LadySnowdrop
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (4)
Creativity (3)
Neatness (4)
Font (3)
Overall Impact (4)
Total (23)
Co-Judges Scoring: 7 + 0
Total Score: 23 + 7 + 0 = 30
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 2nd
K's Ranking: 3rd
Aeriina's Ranking: 4th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: This is such a cute cover and I loved it as soon as I saw it. I love the color scheme and the glow but here are some things that bothered me. The "Sky" was the only word without a glow which makes the cover look a bit awkward. My name is also too big. It would have been better if it matched "Graphics by Eirlys" or at least make it a bit smaller. It was also easy to see that you cropped the picture and placed it on the same color background to have more space for the words. That isn't bad because I do it too but you shouldn't make it obvious. Beautiful cover though, I love it.
Audience Votes: 12
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 🥉3rd Runner Up and 🏆Cat's Pajamas Winner
Contestant: salemdiablo
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (4)
Technique (5)
Creativity (2)
Neatness (5)
Font (4)
Overall Impact (3)
Total (23)
Co-Judges Scoring: 7 + 0
Total Score: 23 + 7 + 0 = 30
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 4th
K's Ranking: 9th
Aeriina's Ranking: 2nd
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: Congratulations for being the winner for The Cat's Pajamas. This was the best cover for me but I have a reason why I didn't put you in my top 3. The cover is almost like a revised version of my example. The purpose of this round was to base a cover based on the plot you were given. I don't think you really followed the prompt given. Also, the title doesn't really have the article "The". Great effort though, really love the aesthetic of this cover.
Audience Votes: 6
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 4th Runner Up
Contestant: rosestar_
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (4)
Creativity (3)
Neatness (4)
Font (3)
Overall Impact (4)
Total (23)
Co-Judges Scoring: 7 + 0
Total Score: 23 + 7 + 0 = 30
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 8th
K's Ranking: 5th
Aeriina's Ranking: 3rd
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: I really like the cover Anyi. It was unique and the color scheme is good. I just think the rain is too long? If you can see what I mean. Like rain drops aren't that long when you see them. Also, the top part of your umbrella looks wonky. The "Town" would have looked better aligned with "Umbrella". Great effort though, just maybe try to work on the drawing and cropping. Everything else was peffect.
Audience Votes: 7
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 5th Runner Up
Contestant: cutie_pixie123
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (5)
Creativity (5)
Neatness (3.5)
Font (3)
Overall Impact (4)
Total (25.5)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6.5 + 0
Total Score: 25.5 + 6.5 + 0 = 32
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 6th
K's Ranking: 4th
Aeriina's Ranking: 7th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: So, I made this before you changed your profile pic. Lol, sorry about that though. Anyways, back to the cover, I really like what you have done with it. It's cute and it fits the prompt really well. The issues I have is the quality (I know how much this annoys yoy by now), and my username. I would have preferred to have it one line. The flowers at the bottom also look a bit messy to me.
Audience Votes: 7
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 6th Runner Up
Contestant: ianshoney
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (3)
Technique (3)
Creativity (1)
Neatness (2)
Legibility of Font (3)
Overall Impact (3)
Total (15)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6.5 + 0
Total Score: 15 + 6.5 + 0 = 21.5
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 5th
K's Ranking: 6th
Aeriina's Ranking: 6th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: I really like your cover this time around sweetie. This was so good and I would have honestly made you the winner of Umbrella Town if you would have changed some things. It's awkward to have your username at the corner, it would have been nicer at the center. My username is not present in the cover and the title could have been bigger and more eye catching. There was so much empty space that it would have been nice if the text brought out the uniqueness since it's a minimalistic cover. I really like this entry though. Good work!
Audience Votes: 5
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 7th Runner Up
Contestant: Juhiwrites
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (3)
Creativity (5)
Neatness (2)
Legibility of Font (1)
Overall Impact (1)
Total (17)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6 + 0
Total Score: 17 + 6 + 0 = 23
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 11th
K's Ranking: 1st
Aeriina's Ranking: 10th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: Your entry has got to be the most unique one so far. I love the entry you chose but your font made me rank you lower. You had 3 different colors of fonts. It would have been more clean if you made "Sky" orange, just like the word "Gold". My name is also too big and hard to read. It would have been nice to not use a cursive font for author names. Just a simple font smilar to "Graphic by Juhi" would have sufficed.
Audience Votes: 3
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 8th Runner Up
Contestant: cutelyy_
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (5)
Technique (4)
Creativity (4)
Neatness (4)
Font (2)
Overall Impact (3)
Total (22)
Co-Judges Scoring: 5 + 0
Total Score: 22 + 5 + 0 = 27
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 7th
K's Ranking: 7th
Aeriina's Ranking: 11th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: It's such a shame. Out of all the Umbrella Town entries, your cover concept was my favorite because you followed the plot. You actually had the mayor at the background. I love that attention to detail. I think the reason why I didn't love it was because of the line across the title. It was a bit too much. Sometimes it's better to be simple yet effective.
Audience Votes: 1
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 9th Runner Up and 🏅Star of the Round
Contestant: galacticosmic
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (4)
Technique (4)
Creativity (4)
Neatness (1)
Font (1)
Overall Impact (4)
Total (18)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6 + 0
Total Score: 18 + 6 + 0 = 24
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 10th
K's Ranking: 10th
Aeriina's Ranking: 8th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: I know that you're probably surprised or disappointed. I know this round was hard for you and out of your element. I can tell you aren't used to minimalistic covers. Even in a children's book you try to add too much. I preferred this cover more because it looked cleaner. The other one was just too messy and painful to the eyes. I love how you experimented though. At least you tried to be unique. Honestly, I would have changed to a much cleaner font and would have removed the white cat in the background. They honestly seem unnecessary. Don't feel bad though, I could see your efforts but sometimes, learn how to adapt to the prompt.
Audience Votes: 15 (Highest in votes)
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: 10th Runner Up
Contestant: Comatose7
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (3)
Technique (3)
Creativity (5)
Neatness (2)
Legibility of Font (2)
Overall Impact (2)
Total (17)
Co-Judges Scoring: 5 + 0
Total Score: 17 + 5 + 0 = 22
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 9th
K's Ranking: 8th
Aeriina's Ranking: 12th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: You had my favorite concept for Cat's Pajamas. You actually found a cat wearing black pajamas that looks like it could be illustrated for a children's book. My only problem is the font. You misspelled my name. It's not Rosie it's "Roze". The author could have been centered, the title could have been bigger and more eye catching and your username could have just been on the bottom row instead of the tail. Love the work, though. Just keep practicing, I know you can do it!
Audience Votes: 1
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Overall Ranking: Last Place
Contestant: BluishlyPink_
S C O R I N G
My Scoring:
Theme (4)
Technique (3)
Creativity (2)
Neatness (5)
Legibility of Font (2)
Overall Impact (2)
Total (18)
Co-Judges Scoring: 6 + 0
Total Score: 18 + 6 + 0 = 24
R A N K I N G
My Ranking: 12th
K's Ranking: 11th
Aeriina's Ranking: 9th
Stha's Ranking: ---
My Comments: I know this is shocking. I'm honestly sorry that I ranked you so low but you have to see it in my perspective. Although others had bad quality or look messy or look like they just slapped text on a picture yours was just not effective for me. It was simple yes, but it was honestly boring? Like you just got a picture of a cat on a hill. The font isn't even fun to look at. There wasn't anything interesting. Your other cover on the other hand was too much. As much as I like the picture. The stars were unnecessary and it had nothing to do with the plot since there is only 1 cat mentioned in the summary. I know you can do it. It's just this round in particular isn't exactly your best.
Audience Votes: 9
▪︎《 🥀 》▪︎
Amora_Cryor, NiveiS, NALU6999, Yoonique3, _MakeShift_, VisualGraphics and WingsOfMyHeartbeat all have 0 points this round.
Eliminated due to inactivity: dystopianxfiction
Bạn đang đọc truyện trên: Truyen2U.Com