CHAPTER FIVE:

STU'S PARTY

STORES WERE CLOSING early due to the curfew that was now till nine o'clock because of the recent murders and attacks that's been going around. Not many vehicles or people could be seen out on the streets, only parents and families rushing to their homes before they'd possibly be the next victims.

A police car could be seen driving towards the grocery store, which was close to the police station. A group of four could be seen inside as Dewey parked the car off beside the sidewalk, hopping out before he moved his seat so Y/n and Sidney could step out from the back, Tatum walking around the vehicle.

"Sure is quiet." Dewey comments.

Sidney sighs. "God, look at this place. It's The Town That Dreaded Sundown."

"Yeah, I saw that movie. It's about a killer in Texas, huh?" Dewey questions, taking off his sunglasses.

"Hey, guys, just think, if they make a movie about you two, who's gonna play you both?" Tatum states in question.

Sidney shrugs. "I shudder to think."

"I see you as a young Meg Ryan myself." Dewey admits.

"Thanks, Dewey. With my luck, they'd cast Tori Spelling." Sidney replies.

And with that, the three girls were walking off towards the grocery store as the police officer calls out to them, telling them that he'd just be a couple of minutes, making sure to add by telling them not to go too far before he walked off.

"Is Billy gonna be there tonight?" Y/n asks.

"He better not be. I told Stu to keep his mouth shut." Tatum tells her. "I think we can live without the endorphin rush for one night."

The group of three walk into the grocery store, greeting the person at the cash register before Y/n grabbed a cart. For a couple minutes, they were talking as they walked through the aisles, Tatum grabbing whatever she thought was good for a party.

"Billy's right, you know." Y/n speaks up. "Whenever he touches me, I just can't relax. I'm too scared."

Tatum shrugs. "So you have a few intimacy issues because you're not ready. That's no big deal, Y/n. You'll thaw out."

"Yeah, but he has been so patient with me with all the sex stuff." Y/n recalls as Sidney grabs stuff from the freezer. "How many guys would put up with a girlfriend who's sexually anorexic?"

"Billy and his penis don't deserve you, alright?" Tatum insists.

The three turn down another aisle as they fail to notice the pair of eyes watching them, the ghostface mask reflecting on the glass doors of the freezer before he quickly ran off before they could catch him.

* * *

The music in Stu Macher's house was blaring throughout the entire place as it was full of quite a few teenagers, but not too much that the house was crowded of people. The trees around the residence were tall as it was now dark out, the crickets chirping as they hid within the tall grass. Some parked vehicles could be seen that belonged to the teenagers in the house.

Dewey's police car could be seen pulling up to the house before the teenagers were climbing out, giving their goodbyes to the police officer. Everyone cheered once they ventured inside, holding up the snacks they had gotten from the grocery store just a few hours ago before the sun had fully set.

It was only a few minutes after where most of the teenagers found themselves inside of the living room of Stu's house. Y/n was sitting side by side with Sidney, who was looking through horror movies while Randy stood in front of the television, holding up two different movies and trying to see who wanted to watch which.

"The Fog, Terror Train, Prom Night." Sidney lists off as she goes through the movies. "How come Jamie Lee Curtis is in all of these movies?"

Randy crouches down beside the couch, clasping his hands together. "She's the scream queen."

"With a set of lungs like that, she should be." Stu comments from his spot beside Tatum.

Just then, the sound of the doorbell could be heard, to which Stu unwrapped his arms from his girlfriend to jump over the couch and to the door, quickly asking Tatum to grab more beers before he walked off. However, it didn't take him all that long before he was rushing back inside the room.

"You are not gonna believe who's here! It's that chick from Top Story!" Stu exclaims.

"Gale Weathers?" Randy realizes in question, to which Stu nods excitedly.

While everyone else seemed excited, Tatum cursed out loud as she stood up when her eyes caught sight of her older brother walking in with Gale Weathers. Calling out his name, she ushered Dewey over with a gesture of her finger as the rest of the teenagers in the house excitedly and happy greeted the news reporter.

It wasn't all too long before the music had slowly died down as some of the teenagers grabbed their things. Stu stood at the door, bright smile on his face as he watched people walk out of the house so they could head home for the curfew. Many commented on how great of a party it was, thanking the teenager for hosting it as they left.

"Tatum, come on!" Sidney yells out after her and Y/n tried searching for the blonde, turning to Stu. "Do you know where she is?"

Stu shakes his head. "No, I haven't seen her."

All of a sudden, the sound of a yelp as someone comes out from their hiding spot at the front door makes them jump, spinning around to face the culprit. There, hands on both sides of the doorframe, stood Billy as he looked at his best friend, giving him a slight look. Crossing her arms, Y/n gulps as she greets him awkwardly.

"Billy." Stu greets as he rubs his chin with a hum. "What are you doing here?"

"I was hoping I could talk to Y/n alone." Billy admits.

"You know, if Tatum sees you here, she'll draw blood." Sidney comments.

"I'll tell you what. Why don't you guys go up to my parents room? You know, you guys can talk, whatever." Stu suggests with a smile.

Billy narrows his eyes on him. "Subtlety, Stu. You should look it up."

"No, it's okay. We do need to talk." Y/n insists.

As she reaches over and and pulls on his arm a bit, the boy follows behind her with a little smile twitching on his lips. As he passed Stu, Billy made sure to hit him in the stomach before he and Y/n began venturing upstairs, the Becker girl giving Sidney a reassuring nod before they continued up to Stu's parents room.

Sidney stares at the spot Y/n had been in with an unsure expression after watching her and Billy go into Stu's parents room, closing the door behind them. Meanwhile, in the bedroom, it was quiet as Y/n sat on the edge of the bed while Billy placed his jacket down somewhere. Neither of the two said anything as Billy sat down beside her.

"So..." Billy begins, clearing his throat. "...I'm sorry. I've been selfish, and I wanna apologize."

Y/n shakes her head. "No, Billy, I'm the one who's been selfish and self-absorbed with all this stuff that's been happening lately."

"You lost your sister and were almost killed." Billy reminds.

Y/n nods. "Yeah, I know, but you're right. I shouldn't be pushing you away, especially times like this."

A tear fell down the girl's cheek and before she could reach up to wipe it away, Billy beat her to it as his thumb wiped at the tear before his hand stayed rested on her cheek. When his thumb gently grazed along her bottom lip, she pressed a soft kiss to it and this only made Billy lean in before their lips met halfway.

Billy wrapped his arms around her as he pulled her closer, one of his hands coming up to rest at the back of her head as their lips moved in sync. One of her hands reaches down to where his other hand rested at her hip, softly grabbing it as she guided it up and underneath her shirt, stopping until his hand was on her breast.

Billy pulls away, glancing between her lips and her eyes. "Are you sure?"

Only whispering a small 'yeah', the girl nods before they both lean in again. Their lips passionately move together as he gently pushed her down till her back met the mattress of the bed. Billy was on top of her right away. It didn't take too long until they were taking off their jackets, throwing them somewhere in the room.

Taking his lips off hers, Billy latched them onto her neck, slowly moving down to the valley of her breasts as quiet moans escaped past the girl's mouth. When he moved his lips back up near the shell of her ear, she turned her head to press her own against his. When she began sitting up, Billy moved off of her and onto his knees.

Y/n followed in suit, reaching down and pulling her shirt off, discarding it somewhere on the floor. Her boyfriend didn't hesitate to do the same, eyes zooming down on her breasts as she reached to unclasp her bra, revealing her bare top to his eyes for the very first time. Mumbling about how beautiful she looked, he was instantly on her.

Her back met the mattress again as they continued kissing one another, the boy moving down as his mouth latched around her breasts, hands reaching for the zipper of her jeans. Following, Y/n reached down for his jeans, the couple pulling them off until they were completely naked in front of each other.

One of Billy's hands rested on the bed beside her head, the other grabbing at his hardened cock as it glided along her folds. Glancing up at her eyes, once he got the nod to continue, he was pushing in in a slow pace, making sure to go at her speed. Hearing the sharp inhale he took, his hand came up to cup her face, making her look into his eyes.

"It's okay. You're alright." Billy whispers.

She nods as they stare at one another before his cock was all the way inside her. The girl's body slowly began relaxing as he started to move, thrusting in and out of her. Y/n closed her eyes, head tilting back as she moaned from the pleasure, the pain beginning to go away after a moment. Grunts escaped past Billy's lips.

"You feel amazing." Billy grunts out.

Y/n moans. "Fuck, Billy!"

Reaching out, he grabbed ahold of her hands, pinning them to the bed as their fingers intertwined, both of them squeezing. The sound of skin slapping against skin was all that could be heard within Stu's parents bedroom, the echoing sound of shouts from downstairs muffled from the walls and the floor.

Y/n could feel her climax coming and Billy could feel his own as well, though as he quickened his pace, his thrusts becoming sloppy, he silently made sure that she would come before him. A loud moan left her mouth as she reached it, pants following her moans while her grip on his hands tightened.

Billy pulls out of her, causing her now confused eyes to look up at him. "I want you to ride me."

She doesn't even hesitate as she sits up, moving to her knees while Billy laid down in the spot she had just been laying in. His hands hold her waist as he guides his cock to her pussy, a groan of pleasure leaving him when she slowly sinks down onto him. Hands coming to rest on his bare chest, Y/n stops for a moment to get used to the pain.

The boy mumbled assuring words to her, hands caressing her hips and waist before she began moving. Their pants could be heard while she moved up and down, bouncing on his hard cock. Billy reaches up, pulling her down until her lips were pressed against his. Their kiss was sloppy, tongues fighting for dominance before the boy won.

They tilted their heads to the side, deepening the kiss when he began thrusting up into her, making her moan out and into his mouth. Y/n could feel him smirking against her lips at the sound, continuing to thrust up into her as she bounced her hips up and down, his cock going deep within inside her.

Pulling away, they rest their foreheads against each other's as she comes around his cock once again. Billy followed right after, pumping himself up and into her, neither of them seeming to care that he wasn't wearing a condom and had just came inside of her. They both stilled after coming, foreheads resting against one another's.

Opening her eyes, Y/n makes eye contact with her boyfriend again, seeing he was staring at her with a smile. She couldn't help but smile as well, his hand coming up to cup her cheek and kiss her passionately.